Notre Dame du Travail: more than meets the eye

If I had to pick only one place to visit on a trip to Paris, it would be Notre Dame du Travail. What makes it so special? It starts with the eye, but there is more than meets the eye.

Philippa and I had rented a flat on rue de Gergovie in the 14th. On a beautiful mid-December day, I took a walk with no purpose other than to breathe in Paris. The entryway seen above struck me as beautiful, but not in the usual Paris way. It was not a grand entryway for those coming to worship or for tourists “doing Paris churches.”

Quite inadvertently, I had entered Notre Dame du Travail on the path taken by community members seeking a variety of services offered by a living church with a history of strong community involvement. It was a comforting and welcoming entrance. Only later did I understand it a bit more.

I am a historian of technology and design. So naturally some things caught my eye more than others. The rugged details and construction that I associate with industrial buildings were exciting, but at the same time reassuring. As I entered the sanctuary, I felt as if I were coming home, or coming to somewhere I belonged. It was a curious feeling.

I was alone, not in a rush, and the views and details did not intrude too quickly.

Had I come through the grand entryway of the front door, this magnificent scene would have welcomed me. Many things caught my eye, but most of all the strength and grace of the exposed structural steel.

Unhurried, I walked into the church. As I looked back towards the nave, I was captivated by the elegance of all that I saw.

Here I am looking towards the aisle and the front of the church. Details slowly crept up on me as I focused more closely. The elegant lectern held my attention, as did the quiet side chapels with their beautiful artwork.

I grew aware of an art nouveau organ cradled between stone and structural iron. I have a fondness for art nouveau, but it was if I was seeing art nouveau for the first time.

I have since learned more about the church that so captivated me.

When the Montparnasse Railway Station in the Plaisance quartier opened in 1840, it marked the beginning of rapid growth and change in this part of Paris. The local parish was known as Notre Dame de l’Assomption de Plaisance. When the quartier became part of Paris in 1860, the parish was renamed Notre Dame de Plaisance.

Montparnasse was a gateway to Paris, and the parish struggled to help meet the needs of an ever-increasing number of working-class residents.

Perhaps no one was better suited for the task of leading this growing parish than the abbé Soulange-Bodin, who was appointed vicar in 1884. Twelve years later (1896), he was appointed parish priest (curé) of the parish of Plaisance. Father Soulange-Bodin was clearly a compassionate man with great love for his often poverty-stricken parishioners and a reputation as a crusader for social justice. More important, he could hold a large vision and combine it with a canny understanding of the times.

He asked questions. Why should the 35,000 parishioners who lived and toiled in the centre of industry not have a church befitting them? In a faubourg of 35,000 workers, why not have a church inspired by their workplaces and the materials—iron and wood—that they handled daily? Why not, in anticipation of the rapidly approaching Grand Exposition of 1900, have a church to welcome the many workers who would come first to build it and then to visit it? Why not a national campaign to build a church to honour the workers of France in a parish composed almost entirely of workers?

Indeed, why not? Money came from many quarters.

What about the design? Although the Eiffel Tower, built in 1889, was still controversial in the late 1890s, it had advanced the image of Paris as a city of iron. It had also highlighted those who erected great works in iron. The well-chosen architect, Jules Astruc (1862-1935), spoke the language of inspiring structural ironwork. He embodied the strong links between French architecture and engineering (one reason why Paris has such wonderful bridges). Above all, the new church had to show respect for those who worked with their hands and were often ill-rewarded for their strengths, skills, hard work, and dedication.

Perhaps I was taken by the church because of my background and upbringing (my father was a miner, then later a carpenter and construction superintendent). But that is a small part of the story. It is less about me than about Father Soulange-Bodin, architect Astruc Jules, and the people they served.

Here the dramatic lighting makes an homage to strength and beauty.

From another point of view, the same material seems so soft and welcoming to the warmth of the art nouveau stencil work.

Notre Dame du Travail is much more than 135 tonnes of iron and steel leavened by respect for workplace materials and forms. Father Soulange-Bodin also wanted to elevate and inspire parishioners through other means. Thus the much-admired art work such as that below.

As I walked out of the church, through the door that one might normally enter, I was struck once again by this church as part of a real, living community. From the front door I could see children playing in a playground and I thought of continuity. Yes, these were the children of more prosperous families than those who had once lived here. Many poor families were displaced when the 4,400 lodgings around the Gare Montparnasse were torn down in the 1960s in a bout of “urban renewal.” But new dwellings were built and Notre Dame du Travail still serves many who need help.

As I stood outside the front of the church I wondered how many people walked by its traditional front façade and failed to realize the drama inside. How close did I come to missing it? I had been attracted by a different and, to me, more interesting entryway.

On a later visit to Paris, Philippa and I were at the Gare St. Lazare. As usual, I was wandering about in dreamy contemplation of design, materials and details. As I gazed at the geometric patterns of the dramatic glass and iron roofs I wondered how many of those who built and maintained them had lived in the 14th.

I thought back to another roof and thanked Father Soulange-Bodin and Jules Astruc for giving me the privilege of seeing the material embodiment of his respect for others and me a new way of looking at the roof of a grand railway station.

It was not easy being poor and we should not glamorize it, but nor should we say there is no place for beauty in poverty. In a wonderful railway station, the memory of a church reminded me of the important place that the quest for beauty and dignity occupy in my life.

Let me end with the roof on the inside and the clock (a gift of emperor Napoleon III to the parish for the previous church on the site) on the outside of something I love and I think I understand.

Text and photographs by Norman R. Ball

About Parisian Fields

Parisian Fields is the blog of two Toronto writers who love Paris. When we can't be there, we can write about it. We're interested in everything from its history and architecture to its graffiti and street furniture. We welcome comments, suggestions, corrections, and musings from all readers.
This entry was posted in Paris churches, Paris history, Paris quartiers and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

14 Responses to Notre Dame du Travail: more than meets the eye

  1. Hazel says:

    I really thought you were going to tell me it was an Eiffel building. I believe the Habitat building on rue du Bac is an Eiffel design.

  2. Hazel says:

    P.S. Norman, it’s Jules Astruc

  3. Alex says:

    Know what I like about many of these articles?

    That I find myself thinking, “Man, I’d really like a closer look at…” and then find that very detail in a photograph a bit farther down the page.

    It’s like we’re related, or something. 🙂

  4. Rob Gorrell says:

    Great post. We will be in Paris next week and I have added this to my must see list.

  5. What a lovely building and article. The art nouveau details are so pleasing and so carefully observed. Very impressive photographs; I will make it a destination on my next trip.

  6. Phil Beard says:

    This is a superb building and beautifully described. I’ve read elsewhere that Astruc employed recycled ironwork from the recently demolished Palais de l’Industrie (from the 1855 Universal Exhibition) for the nave. Did you come across this? It sounds plausible.

    • Thank you for your comments, Phil. The first we heard of recycled ironworks at Notre Dame du Travail was that they included leftover pieces from the Eiffel Tower. I think we can dismiss that rumour pretty quickly. However, I think you are right about using material from the Palais de l’Industrie of 1855.

      But where to find any evidence? In Sur les traces des Expositions universelles Paris 1855- 1937 author and photographer Sylvain Ageorges (Paris: Parigramme, 2006, p. 24) confirms that Jules Astruc, whom he calls “l’ingénieur” (the engineer) “took advantage of the dismantling of the Palace of Industry to reuse large pieces of stone as well as structural metal.” He adds that “the stone facade left nothing to make one suspect the structural iron used in the interior.” (This is our translation of the text.)

      Then he makes a comment which leaves me wanting to know more. “Several covered markets or factories in the Île-dFrance, dating from 1899, lead us to believe that they could well have reused some of the great mass of metal columns of the monumental palace [of industry].”

      Surely there must be more written on this fascinating topic. What happened to the materials from the magnificent 1855 Palais de l’Industrie? Who can help us find out?

  7. Rob Gorrell says:

    Hi again. We visited this church last week. It was wonderful. My wife had not seen any pictures beforehand and was blown away. I ended up talking to a very kind older man in the church for quite a while. His english was much better than he thought it was and my dismal french filled in the gaps. He was so suprised that we had made a point to see the church. He said “How did you find our little church, no one else ever comes here?” He told some great stories about the church and the neighborhood. In spite of the fact that, as he said, “I’m sorry, I am old, I don’t speak much english, and I am deaf”, we got along great. I especially liked the chapels for the saints of artists, carpenters and metalworkers.

    Thanks so much for posting about this church. What a gem.

    Rob

    • Thank you so much for letting us know your thoughts and experiences. It is an extraordinary place, isn’t it? We’re so glad you connected with someone there. That can make such a difference to the whole experience. If you want to add some of the things he told you, we would love to know about them. And do spread the word to others.

  8. erben says:

    I went to Paris on a week long study trip with my class (I study Architecture at a school in northern Sweden) a couple of weeks ago. A group of us went to Notre Dame du Travail on a whim, more or less, and it is by far one of the most beautiful buildings I have seen.

    In a city where sacral spaces are so common, and so overly exuberant, it is very refreshing to see such an honest and relatable building. I am not a religious person at all, quite the contrary actually, but this structure put aside all that. From the fishbone hardwood flooring, via the steel columns to the simple structural elements of the ceiling this structure did indeed feel like it was made for people. Not even just ‘people’ as an abstract word, but individuals and characters with all that comes with it. Every feature of a human being felt welcome here, flaws and all.

    An honest church, that is not something I would have imagined to stumble across in Paris. If you’re reading this while planning a trip to Paris, do yourself a favour and skip the major cathedrals and visit Notre Dame du Travail instead.

  9. I VISITED THIS FASCINATING CHURCH IN DEC 2011. MASS WAS IN PROGRESS SO I WAS UNABLE TO EXPLORE FULLY . GREAT SENSE OF THE ARCHITECTURE OF IRON OF C19. I HAVE BEEN LED TO UNDERSTAND THE STRUCTURAL IRONWORK WAS FROM THE PARIS EXHIBITION OF 1867. MG

  10. Steve thrasher says:

    I saw the church today while I wandering around montparnesse. It interested me and I Google the church. Thanks for the information.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s